Join AMC Theatres, JCPenney, Marshall's, Burlington, P C Richards, Old Navy, Stop & Shop. From 3,600 sf to 25,000 sf available. The Mall at Bay Plaza is the first enclosed fashion mall in the NYC area in almost forty years. Anchored by JCPenney and Macy' s, the Mall at Bay Plaza is a grand New York City shopping destination for a diverse and discerning consumer base from the Bronx, Westchester and Manhattan. At 1.3 million square feet, it is the largest shopping center in New York City with some of the highest performing stores on a per square foot basis for many national, best-in-class retailers. With the addition of The Mall at Bay Plaza, the center' s total size is 2 million square feet. Hutchinson River Parkway & Bartow Avenue.